Chapter 2 - BOARD OF STANDARDS AND APPEALS

Section 25-201

Section 25-201

  §  25-201 Temporary vacancies; filling of. In the event of the absence
or illness of an appointed member, the mayor shall have power to appoint
another person to act in his or her place at  any  meeting  or  meetings
during such period of absence or illness.

Section 25-202

Section 25-202

  § 25-202 Fees. The fees hereinbelow set forth shall be charged for the
following applications, appeals, filings and reviews:
  1.  Zoning  variances.  Application  for any variance under the zoning
resolution with respect to:
  a. (1) Individually owned one and two family dwellings: $ 1,100.00.
  (2) Individually owned three family dwellings: $ 1,700.00.
  b. Other buildings and structures (fee schedule applicable  to  square
footage   involved  in  application),  and  junk  yards,  parking  lots,
automotive  service  stations  and  other  similar  uses  (fee  schedule
applicable to lot area involved in application).
  (1) 10,000 square feet or less of floor area or lot area: $ 3,950.00.
  (2)  In excess of 10,000 but not more than 20,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $ 5,480.00.
  (3) In excess of 20,000 but not more than 40,000 square feet of  floor
area or lot area: $ 7,040.00.
  (4)  In excess of 40,000 but not more than 70,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $ 8,560.00.
  (5) In excess of 70,000 but not more than 100,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $ 10,100.00.
  (6) In excess of 100,000 square feet of floor area: $10,100.00 for the
first 100,000 square feet of floor area plus 5.0% of square  footage  in
units of 10,000 square feet above 100,000 square feet of floor area.
  (7) In excess of 100,000 square feet of lot area: $ 11,200.00.
  c.  All  other  applications  for any zoning variance under the zoning
resolution not subject to paragraph  a  or  b  of  this  subdivision:  $
5,480.00.
  2.  Zoning  special  permits. Application for any special permit under
the zoning resolution with respect to:
  a. (1) Individually owned one and two family dwellings: $ 1,000.00.
  (2) Individually owned three family dwellings: $ 1,570.00.
  b. Other buildings and structures (fee schedule applicable  to  square
footage   involved  in  application),  and  junk  yards,  parking  lots,
automotive  service  stations  and  other  similar  uses  (fee  schedule
applicable to lot area involved in application):
  (1) 10,000 square feet or less of floor area or lot area: $ 2,960.00.
  (2)  In excess of 10,000 but not more than 20,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $ 4,130.00.
  (3) In excess of 20,000 but not more than 40,000 square feet of  floor
area or lot area: $ 5,280.00.
  (4)  In excess of 40,000 but not more than 70,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $ 6,430.00.
  (5) In excess of 70,000 but not more than 100,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $ 7,580.00.
  (6) In excess of 100,000 square feet of floor area: $7,580.00 for  the
first  100,000  square feet of floor area plus 5.0% of square footage in
units of 10,000 square feet above 100,000 square feet of floor area.
  (7) In excess of 100,000 square feet of lot area: $ 8,400.00.
  c. Application for any special permit under the zoning resolution  not
subject to paragraph a or b of this subdivision: $ 4,130.00.
  3. Special order calendar.
  a.  Application  to  reargue  or rehear an application pursuant to the
rules of practice and procedure of the board of standards  and  appeals:
$1,850.00.
  b.   Application  for  amendment  of  a  variance  or  special  permit
previously granted under the zoning resolution with respect to:
  (1) Individually owned one and two family dwellings: $440.00.
  (2) Individually owned three family dwellings: $920.00.
  (3) All other developments: $2,110.00.

  c. Application for an extension of time:
  (1)  To  obtain a certificate of occupancy pursuant to a resolution of
the board of standards and appeals: $1,200.00.
  (2) To complete construction pursuant to section 72-23 or 73-70 of the
zoning resolution: $1,200.00.
  d. Application for extension of term of a variance or  special  permit
previously   granted   under  the  zoning  resolution  with  respect  to
individually owned one, two or three family dwellings,  other  buildings
and  structures  (fee  schedule applicable to square footage involved in
application), and junkyards, parking lots, automotive  service  stations
and  other similar uses (fee schedule applicable to lot area involved in
application):
  (1) Individually owned one, two or three family dwellings: $550.00.
  (2) 10,000 square feet or less of floor area or lot area: $2,370.00.
  (3) In excess of 10,000 but not more than 20,000 square feet of  floor
area or lot area: $3,290.00.
  (4)  In excess of 20,000 but not more than 40,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $4,220.00.
  (5) In excess of 40,000 but not more than 70,000 square feet of  floor
area or lot area: $5,140.00.
  (6) In excess of 70,000 but not more than 100,000 square feet of floor
area or lot area: $6,060.00.
  (7)  In excess of 100,000 square feet of floor area: $6,060.00 for the
first 100,000 square feet of floor area plus 5.0% of square  footage  in
units of 10,000 square feet above 100,000 square feet of floor area.
  (8) In excess of 100,000 square feet of lot area: $6,720.00.
  (9) All other applications: $ 3,290.00.
  e.  Application  to  waive  the rules of practice and procedure of the
board of standards and appeals when:
  (1) Application to extend time to complete construction is  filed  one
year or less after the permitted filing period: $660.00.
  (2)  Application to extend time to complete construction is filed more
than one year after the permitted filing period: $920.00.
  (3) Application to extend the term of a  previously  issued  variance,
special  permit  or  appeal  is  filed  one  year  or  less be after the
permitted filing period: $1,180.00.
  (4) Application to extend the term of a  previously  issued  variance,
special  permit  or appeal, is filed between one and two years after the
permitted filing period: $1,850.00.
  (5) Application to extend the term of a  previously  issued  variance,
special  permit  or  appeal,  is  filed  more  than  two years after the
permitted filing period: $2,630.00.
  (6) Application to extend the term of a  previously  issued  variance,
special  permit  or  appeal,  is  filed  more  than  ten years after the
permitted filing period: $5,000.
  f. Application for minor amendment that is in  substantial  compliance
with previous grant: $ 930.00.
  4. Appeals.
  a.  Application  to  waive  section  thirty-five  or thirty-six of the
general city law with respect to:
  (1) One,  two  and  three  family  residences,  per  building  permit:
$790.00.
  (2) All other residences, per building permit: $1,540.00.
  (3)   All   other  buildings  and  properties,  per  building  permit:
$1,980.00.
  b. Appeal from or application for review of any order, requirement  or
determination  of  the  commissioner  of  buildings  or  of  any borough
superintendent  of  the  department  of  buildings  or   of   the   fire

commissioner  or  any  rule or regulation or amendment or repeal thereof
made by the fire commissioner or  the  commissioner  of  small  business
services with respect to:
  (1)  One,  two  and  three  family  residences,  per  building permit:
$1,260.00.
  (2) All other residences, per building permit: $2,460.00.
  (3)  All  other  buildings  and  properties,  per   building   permit:
$3,160.00.
  c.  Application  to vest building permit under the common law doctrine
of vested rights with respect to:
  (1) One,  two  and  three  family  residences,  per  building  permit:
$940.00.
  (2) All other residences, per building permit: $2,460.00.
  (3)   All   other  buildings  and  properties,  per  building  permit:
$3,160.00.
  d. Application for amendment of prior  approval  of  appeals  from  or
application for review of any order, requirement or determination of the
commissioner  of  buildings  or  of  any  borough  superintendent of the
department of buildings or of the  fire  commissioner  or  any  rule  or
regulation  or amendment or repeal thereof made by the fire commissioner
or the commissioner of small business services with respect to:
  (1) One, two and three family residences: $920.00.
  (2) All other developments: $2,110.00
  5. Application  for  extension  of  period  to  complete  construction
pursuant to section 11-33 of the zoning resolution:
  a. One, two and three family residences, per building permit: $940.00.
  b. All other residences, per building permit: $ 3,690.00.
  c.   All   other   buildings  and  properties,  per  building  permit:
$ 4,740.00.
  6. Exemptions. The provisions of this section shall  not  apply  if  a
municipal department or agency of the city is the applicant or appellant
before the board of standards and appeals.
  7.  Other. Request to obtain off-site file of previous applications to
the board of standards and appeals: $50.00.

Section 25-203

Section 25-203

  §  25-203  Board's  orders;  violation;  penalty. Any person who shall
knowingly violate or fail to comply with any lawful order or requirement
of the board made under the authority of sections six hundred  sixty-six
and  six  hundred  sixty-eight  of  the  charter  shall  be  guilty of a
misdemeanor; and in addition thereto,  and  in  addition  to  all  other
liabilities and penalties imposed by law, shall forfeit and pay for each
such  violation and non-compliance respectively, a penalty in the sum of
not more than two hundred and fifty dollars, as  may  be  fixed  by  the
court  awarding  judgment  therefor.  An  action  may be brought for the
recovery of any such penalty or penalties in the  New  York  city  civil
court or any other court of record in the city, in the name of the city.

Section 25-204

Section 25-204

  §  25-204  Non-appealable  orders. The following are not appealable to
the board:
  1. An order requiring an unsafe building, staging or structure  to  be
made safe;
  2.  An order, requirement, decision or determination made with respect
to or under the provisions of section 26-127 of  the  code  and  article
eight  of  subchapter  three  of  chapter one of title twenty-six of the
code.

Section 25-205

Section 25-205

  §  25-205  Multiple dwelling law not to be varied. The board shall not
vary or modify the multiple dwelling law nor any  order,  regulation  or
ruling  of  the  commissioner  of  housing preservation and development,
except as provided in section three hundred ten of the multiple dwelling
law, and except that any such order, regulation or ruling  issued  under
the  provisions  of chapter two of title twenty-seven of the code may be
varied or modified by the board to the extent permitted by such  chapter
in  the  manner  and  subject  to the conditions therein specified. This
section shall not deprive the board of any of its powers  of  review  on
appeal.

Section 25-206

Section 25-206

  §  25-206  Decision on appeals; form of. The decision on appeals shall
be in writing and, so far as is practicable, shall be in the form  of  a
general  statement  or  resolution  which  shall  be applicable to cases
similar to  or  falling  within  the  principles  passed  upon  in  such
decision.

Section 25-207

Section 25-207

  §  25-207  Certiorari.  a. Petition. Any person or persons, jointly or
severally aggrieved by any decision of the  board  may  present  to  the
supreme court a petition duly verified, setting forth that such decision
is  illegal,  in  whole  or  in  part,  specifying  the  grounds  of the
illegality. Such petition must be presented to a justice of the  supreme
court or at a special term of the supreme court within thirty days after
the filing of the decision in the office of the board.
  b.  Order  of  certiorari. Upon the presentation of such petition, the
justice or court may allow an order of certiorari directed to the  board
to  review  such  decision  and  shall prescribe therein the time within
which a return thereto must  be  made  and  served  upon  the  relator's
attorney,  which  shall not be less than ten days and may be extended by
the court or a justice thereof. Such order  shall  be  returnable  at  a
special  term of the supreme court of the judicial district in which the
property affected, or a portion thereof, is situated. The  allowance  of
the  order  shall  not stay proceedings upon the decision appealed from,
but the court may on application, on notice to  the  board  and  on  due
cause shown, grant a restraining order.
  c.  Return  to  order.  The  board shall not be required to return the
original papers acted upon by it, but it shall be sufficient  to  return
certified  or sworn copies thereof or of such portions thereof as may be
called for by such order. The return must concisely set forth such other
facts as may be pertinent and  material  to  show  the  grounds  of  the
decisions appealed from and must be verified.
  d.  Proceedings  upon return. If, upon the hearing, it shall appear to
the court that testimony is necessary for the proper disposition of  the
matter,  it may take evidence or appoint a referee to take such evidence
as it may direct and report the same  to  the  court  with  his  or  her
findings  of  fact and conclusions of law, which shall constitute a part
of the proceedings upon which the determination of the  court  shall  be
made.  The  court may reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify
the decision brought up for review.
  e. Costs. Costs shall not be allowed  against  the  board,  unless  it
shall  appear to the court that it acted with gross negligence or in bad
faith or with malice in making the decision appealed from.
  f. Preferences. All issues in any proceeding under this section  shall
have preference over all other civil actions and proceedings.