Article 216 - UNSAFE BUILDINGS

Section 28-216.1

Section 28-216.1

  §28-216.1 Conditions constituting an unsafe building or structure. Any
building,  structure  or part thereof described in this article shall be
deemed an unsafe building and shall be demolished  or  removed  or  made
safe and secure as provided herein.

Section 28-216.1.1

Section 28-216.1.1

  §28-216.1.1  Compromised structures. Any structure or premises or part
of a structure or premises that from any cause may at  any  time  become
dangerous  or  unsafe, structurally or as a fire hazard, or dangerous or
detrimental to human life, health or safety,  shall  be  demolished  and
removed or made safe and secure.

Section 28-216.1.2

Section 28-216.1.2

  §28-216.1.2  Vacant  buildings.  Any  vacant building not continuously
guarded or not sealed and kept secure against unauthorized  entry  shall
have  all  openings sealed in a manner approved by the commissioner, and
it shall be the duty of the owner thereof promptly to make  any  repairs
that  may  be  necessary for the purpose of keeping such building sealed
and secure.

Section 28-216.10

Section 28-216.10

  §28-216.10  Judgment  lien.  Any  judgment  rendered  in  an action or
proceeding instituted under this article shall be and become a lien upon
the premises named in such action or proceeding, such lien to date  from
the  time  of  filing a notice of pendency in the office of the clerk of
the county wherein the property affected by such action  or  proceeding,
is  located.  Every such lien shall have priority before any mortgage or
other lien as may exist prior to such filing except tax  and  assessment
liens.

Section 28-216.11

Section 28-216.11

  §28-216.11  Tax lien. Any costs and expenses incurred by any agency of
the city pursuant to this article, including  but  not  limited  to  the
preliminary  expenses  of  searches, service of the notice of survey and
summons on interested parties, surveys thereof, and costs  of  executing
the  precept, shall be a debt recoverable from the owner of the premises
and a lien upon the land and buildings upon or in respect to which  such
costs  and  expenses  were incurred. Every such lien shall have priority
over all other liens and encumbrances on the  premises  except  for  the
lien  of  taxes and assessments. Except as otherwise provided by rule of
the affected agency, the agency incurring such expense shall be governed
by the procedures set forth in article eight of subchapter five  of  the
housing  maintenance  code  with respect to the enforcement of such debt
and lien.

Section 28-216.12

Section 28-216.12

  §28-216.12  Buildings and structures that are potentially compromised.
For purposes of this section 28-216.12, "potentially compromised"  shall
include a building or structure that has had an open roof for sixty days
or  longer,  that  has been shored and braced or repaired pursuant to an
emergency declaration issued by the commissioner, that has been  subject
to  a  precept as a compromised structure under Article 216 of this code
or that may have suffered structural damage by fire or  other  cause  as
determined by the commissioner.

Section 28-216.12.1

Section 28-216.12.1

  §28-216.12.1   Structural   inspections   of  potentially  compromised
buildings or  structures.  When  a  building  or  structure  has  become
potentially  compromised,  the owner shall cause a structural inspection
of such building or structure to be performed. Such inspection shall  be
performed  within  sixty  days  of the opening of the roof, within sixty
days of the shoring and bracing or repair work, or within sixty days  of
a  determination  by  the  commissioner  that  the building has suffered
structural damage by fire or other cause. A report  of  such  inspection
shall be filed with the department within thirty days thereafter in such
form  and  detail  and  with  provision  for  periodic monitoring of the
building or structure as the commissioner may require.

Section 28-216.12.2.

Section 28-216.12.2.

  §28-216.12.2.  Structural  inspections  shall  only  be performed by a
registered design professional in good standing with the New York  state
department of education.

Section 28-216.12.3.

Section 28-216.12.3.

  §28-216.12.3.  If  a violation of any applicable statute, law, rule or
regulation or any unsafe condition that poses a threat to the structural
integrity of the building or to the public is found during the course of
such inspection,  the  registered  design  professional  performing  the
inspection shall immediately notify the department and the owner of such
violation or unsafe condition by calling 311 and in writing.

Section 28-216.12.4.

Section 28-216.12.4.

  §28-216.12.4. An inspection of the buildings and structures subject to
the  inspection  and  filing  requirements of section 28-216.12 shall be
performed every year or, for a specified building or  structure,  within
such  other period as determined by the commissioner but not longer than
two years, and shall continue until such time as the  registered  design
professional  documents  and certifies that the building or structure is
no longer potentially compromised and such certification is accepted  by
the commissioner.

Section 28-216.12.5.

Section 28-216.12.5.

  §28-216.12.5. The owner shall hire a registered design professional to
perform  a  structural inspection of buildings and structures subject to
section 28-216.12 prior to the issuance of a permit  to  alter,  repair,
demolish  or  enlarge  such  building  or  structure,  except  that  the
commissioner may waive such inspection if a structural inspection of the
entire building or structure has been performed within the prior year.

Section 28-216.12.6.

Section 28-216.12.6.

  §28-216.12.6.  Any  owner  of a building or structure shall notify the
department in  writing  that  such  building  or  structure  has  become
potentially  compromised  immediately  after  such owner knows or should
have known of the condition. Such notice  shall  contain  the  name  and
business  address  of  the owner of record of such building or structure
and shall identify the building or structure by street address  and  tax
block and lot. The notices required by this subdivision shall be in such
form and manner as established by the commissioner by rule.

Section 28-216.12.7.

Section 28-216.12.7.

  §28-216.12.7.  If  an  owner  subject  to  the  inspection  and filing
requirements of this section fails to file such report, the owner  shall
be  liable  for  a civil penalty in an amount not less than two thousand
dollars.  In  such  a  case,  the  department  may  cause  a  structural
inspection to be conducted and a report filed.

Section 28-216.2

Section 28-216.2

  §28-216.2 Record and notice of unsafe building, structure or premises.
The  department  shall cause a report to be filed on an unsafe building,
structure or premises. The report  shall  describe  the  nature  of  the
occupancy of the structure and the nature of the unsafe condition and be
made a record of the department.

Section 28-216.3

Section 28-216.3

  §28-216.3  Notice  and  order.  The  owner,  executor,  administrator,
mortgagee, lessee or any other person who may have a recorded vested  or
recorded  contingent  interest  in  the  unsafe  building,  structure or
premises, shall be served with a notice containing a description of  the
unsafe  building,  structure  or  premises  and  an order requiring such
building be vacated pursuant to  28-207.4,  if  necessary,  and  sealed,
secured,  repaired,  shored,  or demolished and removed as may be deemed
necessary by the department.

Section 28-216.3.1

Section 28-216.3.1

  §28-216.3.1  Content. Such notice shall require the person thus served
immediately to certify to  the  department  his  or  her  acceptance  or
rejection  of  the order. The notice shall further notify said person(s)
that upon his or her refusal or  neglect  to  comply  with  any  of  the
requirements  of  this  provision,  a survey of the building or premises
named in such notice will be made at a time and place therein named. The
notice shall also state that if, pursuant to the  survey,  it  is  found
that  the building, structure, or premises referred to therein is unsafe
or dangerous by the surveyors, their report of  survey  will  be  placed
before  the  supreme  court  for trial at a time and place named in such
notice.

Section 28-216.4

Section 28-216.4

  §28-216.4  Method  of service. The notice and order shall be served in
accordance with the civil practice law and rules of  the  state  of  New
York.

Section 28-216.5

Section 28-216.5

  §28-216.5  Owner  abatement  of unsafe or dangerous conditions. If the
person served with a notice and order pursuant to section 28-216.4 shall
immediately certify his or her assent to the securing or removal of such
unsafe building, structure or premises condition, such person  shall  be
allowed  a  period  of time as determined by the commissioner, or his or
her designee, within which to commence and complete the abatement of the
unsafe or dangerous condition. Such person shall employ sufficient labor
and assistance to secure or remove such conditions as  expeditiously  as
possible.

Section 28-216.6

Section 28-216.6

  §28-216.6  Survey.  A  survey  of  the  building  or premises shall be
conducted as follows:

Section 28-216.6.1

Section 28-216.6.1

  §28-216.6.1  Identity  of surveyors. The survey shall be made by three
competent persons, of whom one shall be the commissioner or his  or  her
designee; another shall be a registered design professional appointed by
a  recognized  professional  organization;  and  the  third  shall  be a
registered design professional appointed by the  person  served  with  a
notice  pursuant  to  section  28-216.4.  If the person served with such
notice shall neglect or refuse to appoint such surveyor, the  other  two
surveyors  shall  make  the  survey.  In  case they disagree, they shall
appoint a third person to take part in  such  survey,  who  shall  be  a
registered  design  professional  of  at least 10 years' practice, whose
decision shall be final.

Section 28-216.6.2

Section 28-216.6.2

  §28-216.6.2  Posting  report  of  survey.  A copy of the report of the
survey shall be posted on the structure that is the subject  thereof  by
the  persons  holding  the  survey,  immediately  on  their issuing such
report.

Section 28-216.6.3

Section 28-216.6.3

  §28-216.6.3   Compensation   of   surveyors.   The  registered  design
professional appointed by the respective professional  organization,  as
herein  before  provided, who may act on any survey called in accordance
with the provisions of this section 28-216.6, and the third surveyor who
may have been called in the case of disagreement provided  for  in  this
section  28-216.6,  shall each be paid a sum to be determined by rule to
be promulgated by the department.

Section 28-216.6.4

Section 28-216.6.4

  §28-216.6.4  Cost  of  survey.  Any  costs  incurred  by  the  city in
connection with the survey shall become money due and owing to the  city
as  part  of  the return of precept and judgment provided for in section
28-216.9 and 28-216.10 of this code or pursuant to lien provided for  in
section 28-112.9 of this code.

Section 28-216.7

Section 28-216.7

  §28-216.7 Court proceeding. Whenever the report of survey shall recite
that   the  building,  structure  or  premises  surveyed  is  unsafe  or
dangerous, the corporation counsel or his or her designee shall, at  the
time  specified  in  the  notice,  place such notice and report before a
justice of the court named in the notice. The report of survey shall  be
in  writing  and constitute the issues to be placed before the court for
trial. The purpose of the trial shall be to determine whether the unsafe
building, structure, or premises shall be vacated and  sealed,  secured,
shored, or demolished and removed.

Section 28-216.7.1

Section 28-216.7.1

  §28-216.7.1  Precedence  of proceeding. The unsafe building proceeding
shall have precedence over every other business of such  supreme  court.
The  trial on the issues in the unsafe building proceeding shall be held
without delay, at the time specified in the notice, and shall be held by
a justice of the court or by a referee, whose decision or report in  the
matter shall be final.

Section 28-216.7.2

Section 28-216.7.2

  §28-216.7.2 Precept to abate. If the justice or referee determines the
building,  structure  or  premises  that is the subject of the report of
survey is unsafe or dangerous, such justice or referee trying  the  case
shall   immediately   issue  a  precept  directed  to  the  commissioner
authorizing the commissioner forthwith to  vacate  pursuant  to  section
28-207.4,  if  necessary,  and  to  seal, secure, shore, or demolish and
remove the unsafe building, structure or premises named in such  report.
The precept shall be effective for a period of three years from the date
of issuance.

Section 28-216.7.3

Section 28-216.7.3

  §28-216.7.3 Notice of pendency. A notice of pendency shall be filed in
accordance with the following procedure:
  1.  The  notice  of  pendency  shall  consist  of a copy of the notice
described in section 28-216.3 and shall be filed in the  office  of  the
clerk  of the county where the property affected by such action, suit or
proceeding is located. Such notice of pendency may be filed at any  time
after the service of the notice described in section 28-216.3.
  2.  Any  notice  of  pendency filed pursuant to the provisions of this
section 28-216.7.3 that has not expired may be vacated and cancelled  of
record  upon  an  order  of a justice of the court in which such suit or
proceeding was instituted or is pending, or upon the consent in  writing
of  the corporation counsel. The clerk of the county where the notice is
filed is hereby directed  and  required  to  mark  any  such  notice  of
pendency,  and any record or docket thereof, as vacated and cancelled of
record upon the presentation and filing of  a  certified  copy  of  such
order or consent.

Section 28-216.8

Section 28-216.8

  §28-216.8  Execution  of precept. A precept issued pursuant to section
28-216.7.2 shall be executed in accordance with the procedure set  forth
in sections 28-216.8.1 through 28-216.8.3.

Section 28-216.8.1

Section 28-216.8.1

  §28-216.8.1 Work by the department. Upon receiving a precept under the
provisions  of  section  28-216.7.2, the commissioner shall execute such
precept, as therein directed, and may employ such labor  and  assistance
and  furnish  such  materials  as may be necessary for that purpose. The
commissioner or his or her designee shall  direct  the  commissioner  of
citywide   administrative   services   or   the  department  of  housing
preservation and development or other authorized agency to perform  work
in accordance with the precept. Such work shall be performed by or under
the direction of citywide administrative services in accordance with the
provisions   of  section  4-204  of  the  administrative  code,  or  the
department of  housing  preservation  and  development,  or  such  other
authorized agency.

Section 28-216.8.2

Section 28-216.8.2

  §28-216.8.2  Owner  application  to  perform  work.  The owner of such
unsafe  building,  structure,  or  premises,  or  any  party  interested
therein, if such person applies to the commissioner immediately upon the
issuing of such precept, shall be allowed to perform the requirements of
such  precept  at  his  or  her own cost and expense, if the performance
shall be done immediately and in accordance  with  the  requirements  of
such  precept  and  other  applicable  laws  and  rules  and  such other
requirements as the commissioner shall impose.

Section 28-216.8.3

Section 28-216.8.3

  §28-216.8.3  Modification  of  precept. The commissioner or his or her
designee shall have authority to modify the requirements of any  precept
when  such  commissioner or designee shall be satisfied that such change
will secure the safety of such structure or premises equally well.

Section 28-216.8.3.1

Section 28-216.8.3.1

  §28-216.8.3.1  Upon  application.  The  commissioner  shall  also have
authority to modify the requirements of any precept upon application  to
such  commissioner  in  writing  by  the  owner  of the unsafe building,
structure, or premises, or such owner's  authorized  representative.  In
addition,  upon application to modify the requirements of any precept to
seal or shore the structure by the commissioner of housing  preservation
and   development,   citywide  administrative  services  or  such  other
authorized agency, the commissioner or designee shall have authority  to
modify such precept accordingly when the commissioner shall be satisfied
that  such  change  will secure the safety of such structure or premises
equally well.

Section 28-216.8.3.2

Section 28-216.8.3.2

  §28-216.8.3.2  Notice.  After a determination to modify the precept is
made by the commissioner, written notice of such determination shall  be
sent  by regular mail to the owner and applicant for the modification if
other than the owner, at his or her last known address.

Section 28-216.8.3.3

Section 28-216.8.3.3

  §28-216.8.3.3  Failure  of  owner  to  perform  work.  If no action in
accordance with the modified precept  is  undertaken  by  the  owner  or
applicant  for  modification  within  the  time  period  provided in the
modification  following  the   granting   of   such   application,   the
commissioner  may  direct  the  department  of  housing preservation and
development or the department of  citywide  administrative  services  or
such  other  authorized agency to execute the original precept, provided
however that prior to  such  execution,  notice  shall  be  provided  by
regular  mail to the owner of the unsafe building, structure or premises
and applicant for the modification if other than the owner,  at  his  or
her  last  known  address. The owner shall continue to have the right to
request the commissioner to modify the requirements of the precept prior
to the execution thereof.

Section 28-216.8.4

Section 28-216.8.4

  §28-216.8.4  Interference  prohibited.  It  shall  be unlawful for any
person  to  interfere,  obstruct  or  hinder  the  commissioner  or  the
commissioner  of  citywide administrative services, housing preservation
and development, or other authorized agency, or any person  who,  acting
under  the  authority  conferred on such person by such commissioner, in
performing the work authorized by a precept issued out of any  court  or
modified  in  accordance  with  §28-216.8.3,  or the work ordered by the
commissioner in accordance with such precept  under  the  provisions  of
section 28-216.8.3.3.

Section 28-216.8.5

Section 28-216.8.5

  §28-216.8.5  Enforcement.  The  police commissioner shall enforce such
orders or requirements when requested  by  the  commissioner  and  shall
likewise  enforce  same  at  the request of the commissioner of citywide
administrative services, housing preservation and development, or  other
authorized  agency,  with  respect  to  work  performed  by or under the
direction of such commissioner pursuant to  the  provisions  of  section
28-216.8.3.3.

Section 28-216.9

Section 28-216.9

  §28-216.9 Return of precept and reimbursement of city. Upon compliance
with  any  precept issued to the commissioner in a proceeding under this
article, the commissioner may make return thereof, with  an  endorsement
of the action thereunder and the costs and expenses thereby incurred, to
the  justice  of  the court from which such precept issued. Such justice
shall then tax and adjust the amount endorsed  upon  such  precept,  and
shall  adjust  and allow the disbursements of the proceeding, including,
but not limited to the preliminary expenses of searches, service of  the
notice of survey and summons on interested parties, surveys thereof, and
costs  of executing the precept, which shall be inserted in the judgment
in such proceeding. Such justice shall then  render  judgment  for  such
amount  and  for the sale of the premises named in such notice, together
with all the right, title and interest that the  person  named  in  such
notice  had  in  the  lot,  ground or land upon which such structure was
placed, at the time of the filing  of  a  notice  of  pendency  in  such
proceedings, or at the time of the entry of judgment therein, to satisfy
such judgment in foreclosure of mortgages. Nothing in this article shall
preclude  the  city from recovering such costs and expenses in any other
lawful manner, including pursuant to section 28-112.9 of this code.