Chapter 6 - DRUG TESTING OF SCHOOL SYSTEM CONVEYANCE DRIVERS

Section 17-601

Section 17-601

  §  17-601  Definitions.  As  used in this chapter, the following terms
shall be defined as follows:
  a. "Driver" or "Bus driver" shall mean  every  person  employed  by  a
motor  carrier  who  drives and operates a bus or other motor vehicle to
transport school children and every person employed by a  motor  carrier
who  drives  and  operates  a  mobile  instructional  unit pursuant to a
contract between the motor carrier and the board of education.
  b. "Motor carrier" shall mean any person, corporation, or  entity  who
operates  or  employs others to operate buses or other motor vehicles to
transport school children and any person,  corporation,  or  entity  who
operates  or  employs  others  to  operate  mobile  instructional  units
pursuant to a contract with the board of education.
  c. "The department" shall mean the New York city department of  health
and mental hygiene.
  d.  "Board" or "Board of education" shall mean the New York city board
of education.
  e. "Illegal drug"  shall  mean  marijuana  or  concentrated  cannabis,
cocaine  and  its  derivatives, opiates, amphetamines, phencyclidine and
any other drug the board of education shall designate by  rule  pursuant
to section 17-609 of this chapter.
  f.  "Drug test" shall mean a scientific procedure employing an initial
screening test  and,  where  required  by  this  chapter,  a  subsequent
confirmatory test on urine to detect the presence of illegal drugs.
  g. "Sample" shall mean a portion of a urine specimen used for testing.
  h.  "Screening  test" shall mean an immunoassay screen using a test at
least as reliable as the enzyme multiplied immunoassay test.
  i. "Confirmatory  test"  shall  mean  a  second  analytical  procedure
performed  on  a  different  sample of the same specimen that has tested
positive on the screening test.
  j. "Pre-employment test" shall mean a drug test given to an  applicant
for the position of driver.
  k.  "Random  test"  shall  mean  a  drug  test  given  annually  to  a
predetermined percentage of drivers who are selected on a scientifically
defensible random and unannounced basis.
  l. "Post-accident test" shall mean  a  drug  test  administered  to  a
driver  after  a  serious accident or series of accidents, as defined in
section 17-607, has occurred during his or her operation  of  a  bus  or
other motor vehicle in the course of his or her employment.
  m.  "Return to duty test" shall mean a drug test given to a driver who
previously tested positive to a drug test and  is  returning  to  active
duty,  and  any  additional,  unannounced  drug  test administered for a
period of up to sixty months after a positive test result.
  n. "Serious accident" shall  mean  an  accident  associated  with  the
operation  of  a  bus  or  other  motor vehicle used to transport school
children in which an individual dies or  must  be  taken  to  a  medical
treatment  facility, or in which property damage is estimated to be more
than two thousand five hundred dollars.
  o. "Chain of custody procedures" shall mean procedures to account  for
the  integrity  of  each  urine  specimen  by  tracking its handling and
storage from point of specimen collection to final  disposition  of  the
specimen.
  p.   "Medical   review   officer"  shall  mean  a  licensed  physician
responsible for receiving and interpreting laboratory results  generated
by a drug testing program.
  q.  "Positive  test result" shall mean that the drug test result shows
positive evidence that an illegal drug is present in a  driver's  system
in  a  level  established  by the board of education pursuant to section
17-609.

  r. "Pass a drug test" shall mean that a  medical  review  officer  has
determined,  pursuant  to  section  17-609 herein, that the results of a
drug test administered under this chapter: (1)  showed  no  evidence  or
insufficient  evidence  of  an  illegal  drug; (2) showed evidence of an
illegal  drug  but  there  was  a legitimate medical explanation for the
result; (3) were scientifically insufficient to warrant further  action;
or  (4)  were suspect because of irregularities in the administration of
the test or observation of chain of custody procedures.
  s. "Active duty" shall mean the operation of  a  bus  or  other  motor
vehicle used for the transportation of school children.
  t.  "School  year"  shall mean the period of time commencing September
first and ending on August thirty-first.
  u. "Mobile instructional unit" shall mean a vehicle in which federally
mandated educational services are provided to eligible non-public school
children pursuant to title I of the Elementary and  Secondary  Education
Act of 1965, as amended.

Section 17-602

Section 17-602

  §  17-602  Drug  testing of school system drivers. Every motor carrier
shall certify to the board of education that  it  requires  all  drivers
employed by such motor carrier to submit to pre-employment drug testing,
random  drug  testing,  reasonable suspicion drug testing, post-accident
drug testing and return to duty drug testing,  in  accordance  with  the
requirements of this chapter and any rules promulgated pursuant hereto.

Section 17-603

Section 17-603

  §  17-603  Prior  notice  of  testing policy. At the beginning of each
school year, every motor carrier shall give written notice of  its  drug
testing  policy,  as  provided  by  the  board  of education pursuant to
section 17-609(d)(2) of this chapter, to all drivers employed by it. The
written notice shall contain the following  information:  the  need  for
drug testing; the procedure for confirming an initial positive drug test
result; the right to obtain an additional drug test on the same specimen
at  the  driver's own expense; the consequences pursuant to this chapter
of not passing a drug test or refusing to take  a  drug  test;  and  the
right to explain a positive test result.

Section 17-604

Section 17-604

  §  17-604  Pre-employment testing. For the purposes of this chapter, a
motor carrier shall not hire or assign an individual as a driver  unless
he  or  she passes a drug test in accordance with the provisions of this
chapter.

Section 17-605

Section 17-605

  §  17-605  Random  testing. a. All drivers employed by a motor carrier
subject to  this  chapter  shall  be  subject  to  drug  testing  on  an
unannounced and random basis.
  b.  During  the  school  year  commencing September 1, 1990 and ending
August 31, 1991, every motor carrier shall administer a number of random
drug tests equal to twenty-five percent of all drivers  employed  during
that  year.  For  each subsequent school year, every motor carrier shall
administer a number of random drug tests equal to fifty percent  of  all
drivers employed by such motor carrier during that year.
  c. Each driver shall be in a pool from which random selection is made.
Each  driver  in  the  pool  shall have an equal chance of selection and
shall remain in the pool after he or she has been tested.
  d. A driver shall be selected for drug testing on a  random  basis  by
using a scientifically valid random number generation method.
  e.  Testing  shall  be  spread  through the twelve-month period of the
school year.
  f. The board of education shall select the dates and times that random
drug tests shall be administered and shall be responsible for the driver
selection process required by subdivision d of this section.

Section 17-606

Section 17-606

  §  17-606  Reasonable suspicion testing. Nothing in this chapter shall
preclude a motor carrier from administering a drug test when  the  motor
carrier  has  a  reasonable  suspicion that a driver is using an illegal
drug or when the chancellor of the board of education,  or  his  or  her
designee,  has  a reasonable suspicion that a driver is using an illegal
drug and requests that a driver take a drug test.

Section 17-607

Section 17-607

  § 17-607 Post-accident testing. a. A drug test must be administered to
any  bus  driver who, during the course of his or her employment, (i) is
involved in a serious accident while operating  a  bus  or  other  motor
vehicle; or (ii) during any twelve month period, is involved in three or
more  accidents while operating a bus or other motor vehicle, regardless
of the amount of property damage caused or injuries sustained.
  b. The specimen for a post-accident drug test required by this section
shall be collected as soon after the accident as is practicable, but not
later than thirty-two hours after the accident. In those cases involving
testing under paragraph (ii) of  subdivision  a  of  this  section,  the
specimen  shall be collected in accordance with the requirements of this
subdivision after the third accident.

Section 17-608

Section 17-608

  §  17-608 Return to active duty testing. A driver who has been removed
from active duty pursuant to this chapter may  not  resume  active  duty
until  he  or  she passes a drug test and the medical review officer has
determined the driver is fit to return to active duty. A driver  who  is
tested  under  this  section may be administered one or more unannounced
drug tests for up to sixty months after returning to active duty.

Section 17-609

Section 17-609

  §  17-609  Drug  testing  procedures.  a.  All drug tests administered
pursuant to this chapter shall  utilize  those  reliable  screening  and
confirmatory  procedures  set forth in rules promulgated by the board of
education which are at  least  as  reliable  as  the  enzyme  multiplied
immunoassay  screening test and the gas chromatography/mass spectrometry
confirmatory test.
  b. If a sample yields a positive test result, another sample from  the
same  specimen  shall  be re-tested using a test at least as reliable as
the gas chromatography/mass spectrometry test. Such a confirmatory  test
shall  use  a  portion  of  the  same  test  specimen collected from the
employee for use in the first test. If such confirmatory test  yields  a
positive  test  result the driver may, at his or her option and expense,
have an additional test conducted on a sample from the same specimen  by
any  laboratory  eligible  to  conduct  drug  testing under this chapter
within thirty days of the administration of the original test.
  c. (1) All test results shall be interpreted and verified by a medical
review officer employed by the motor carrier. The medical review officer
shall  be  a  licensed  physician  with  knowledge  of  substance  abuse
disorders  and appropriate medical training to interpret and evaluate an
individual's test result together with his  or  her  individual  medical
history and any other relevant biomedical information.
  (2)  The  medical  review officer shall (i) receive the results of all
drug tests from the laboratory; (ii) verify that the  laboratory  report
and  assessment  of  all  drug  test  results are reliable and treat the
results as confidential until such verification is made; (iii) determine
whether an individual passes a drug test; (iv) promptly report all  test
results  to  the  driver  in writing; (v) report each test that does not
pass to the individual whom the motor carrier has designated to  receive
the  results  and the chancellor of the board of education or his or her
designee; (vi) recommend to the  motor  carrier  whether  a  driver  who
refused  to  take  or  did  not pass a drug test administered under this
chapter and who passes a subsequent  return  to  active  duty  test  may
return to active duty; and (vii) maintain records of all recommendations
to  the  motor  carrier concerning removal from or return to active duty
and in cases where rehabilitation is not recommended after  a  confirmed
positive  test  result,  the  reasons  for  such recommendation shall be
submitted to the chancellor of the board of  education  or  his  or  her
designee.
  (3)  When reviewing positive results of a confirmatory test under this
section, the  medical  review  officer  may  consider  the  individual's
medical   history,   including   any   medical  records  and  biomedical
information provided, in  determining  whether  there  is  a  legitimate
medical  explanation  for  the  result,  including  the use of a legally
prescribed medication.
  (4) A driver may submit a list of any legally prescribed medication he
or  she  is  using  to  the  medical  review  officer   prior   to   the
administration of a drug test.
  d.  (1) The board of education, in consultation with the department of
health and mental hygiene, shall promulgate rules, which to  the  extent
practicable are consistent with the procedures established by the United
States  department  of  transportation,  to implement this chapter. Such
rules shall include initial cutoff levels  to  be  used  when  screening
urine  specimens  to  determine  whether  they test positive for illegal
drugs, chain of custody procedures to account for the integrity of  each
urine  specimen  by  tracking  its  handling  and  storage from point of
specimen  collection   to   final   disposition,   specimen   collection
procedures,  quality  assurance and quality control programs, procedures

governing the reporting and review of test  results  and  procedures  to
safeguard the confidentiality of drivers.
  (2)  The  board of education shall provide motor carriers with written
guidelines and procedures for the implementation  of  the  drug  testing
program  pursuant  to  this  chapter no later than the effective date of
this local law.
  e. Motor carriers  subject  to  this  chapter  shall  use  only  those
laboratories  certified under the United States department of health and
human services mandatory guidelines for federal workplace  drug  testing
programs  or  approved  by  the  New York state department of health, to
execute the drug testing program required by this chapter.
  f. Laboratories employed by motor carriers to execute the drug testing
program pursuant to this chapter shall report drug test results  to  the
medical review officer in writing within five days after a drug test has
been  administered.  All  drug  test specimens shall be retained by such
laboratories for at least six months.
  g. Two or more motor carriers may join together  for  the  purpose  of
employing  a  medical  review officer and/or a laboratory to comply with
the requirements of this chapter. Notwithstanding  the  foregoing,  each
motor  carrier  shall be individually responsible for complying with the
provisions of this chapter.

Section 17-610

Section 17-610

  §  17-610 Consequences of failure to pass a drug test; refusal to take
a drug test. a. Any driver who does not pass a  drug  test  administered
pursuant  to this chapter shall immediately be removed from active duty.
The  medical  review   officer   may,   where   appropriate,   recommend
rehabilitation  or  other  treatment programs. No driver shall return to
active duty unless he or she submits proof of successful completion of a
rehabilitation program or  other  recommended  treatment  and  passes  a
return to active duty drug test as required by section 17-608.
  b.  Any  driver who does not pass a drug test shall receive within ten
days of the confirmatory test, together with written notification of his
or her test result, written notice of the right to undergo an additional
drug test performed on a sample of the same  specimen,  at  his  or  her
option  and  expense, within thirty days after the administration of the
original drug test.
  c. Any driver who refuses to take a drug  test  shall  immediately  be
removed from active duty for a period of at least one year and shall not
return to active duty until passing a return to active duty drug test as
required by section 17-608.

Section 17-611

Section 17-611

  §   17-611  Recordkeeping  and  reporting.  a.  Motor  carriers  shall
designate an individual or individuals to serve as drug testing  program
designee(s)  to  ensure  compliance  with  this chapter. The designee(s)
shall be responsible for the implementation of the drug testing  program
and maintaining all records related to the administration of drug tests.
Motor  carriers  shall  retain records related to the collection process
and reports of individuals who have not passed a drug test for at  least
five years and records of individuals who have passed a drug test for at
least one year.
  b.  The  medical  review officer shall maintain records of individuals
who have not passed a drug test for at least five years and the  records
of individuals who have passed a drug test for at least one year.
  c.  A  motor  carrier  shall  permit  the  chancellor  of the board of
education or his or her designee to examine all records relating to  the
administration  and  results  of the drug testing program established by
such motor carrier pursuant to this chapter.
  d.  A  motor  carrier  shall  promptly  give  written  notice  to  the
chancellor  of  the board of education or his or her designee whenever a
driver is removed from active duty or returned to active  duty  pursuant
to this chapter. Such written notice shall include the driver's name and
the date of removal from or return to active duty.
  e.  A  motor  carrier shall submit semi-annual reports to the board of
education on April first and October first of each year summarizing  the
following information for the periods from September first through March
first and March second through August thirty-first, respectively:
  (1) The total number of drug tests administered;
  (2)   The   number  of  drug  tests  administered  and  the  dates  of
administration  in  each   testing   category   (i.e.,   pre-employment,
post-accident, reasonable suspicion, random, and return to duty);
  (3)  The number of post-accident drug tests administered and the dates
of administration in  each  accident  category  (i.e.,  fatal,  personal
injury, property damage or three accidents);
  (4)  For post-accident tests, the number of hours between the accident
and the collection of a urine specimen;
  (5) The total number of individuals who did not pass a drug test;
  (6) The number of individuals who did not pass a drug test by  testing
category;
  (7)  The  number  of individuals who did not pass a post-accident drug
test by accident category;
  (8) The action taken  by  the  motor  carrier  with  respect  to  each
individual who did not pass a drug test;
  (9)  The  number of drug tests submitted to the laboratory that showed
evidence of one or more illegal drugs in the immunoassay screening  test
in a sufficient quantity to warrant a confirmatory test;
  (10)  The  total number of drug tests submitted to the laboratory that
showed evidence of one or more illegal drugs in the confirmatory test in
a sufficient quantity to be reported as positive to the  medical  review
officer;
  (11)  The number of drug tests submitted to the laboratory that showed
evidence of one or more illegal drugs in  the  confirmatory  test  in  a
sufficient  quantity  to  be  reported as positive by the medical review
officer;
  (12) Such other relevant information as the board of  education  shall
require.
  f.  The first semi-annual report required by this section shall be due
on April 1, 1991.

Section 17-612

Section 17-612

  § 17-612 Certification of compliance. a. A motor carrier shall certify
to  the board that it has established a drug testing program as required
by the provisions of this chapter. Such certification shall be submitted
to the board of education no later than one month  after  the  effective
date of this chapter, and annually thereafter.
  b.  The text of the certification required by this section shall be as
follows:
  I,              ,                 , certify that has  established  and
implemented  a  drug-testing  program  in  accordance  with the terms of
chapter 6 of Title 17 of the administrative code  of  the  city  of  New
York.

Section 17-613

Section 17-613

  §  17-613  Termination  of  contracts.  The  board  of  education  may
terminate the contract of any motor carrier that does  not  comply  with
the provisions of this chapter.

Section 17-614

Section 17-614

  §  17-614  No  abrogation of rights. Nothing contained in this chapter
shall limit any right of a  motor  carrier  to  terminate  or  otherwise
discipline any of its drivers who fail to pass a drug test.

Section 17-615

Section 17-615

  §  17-615 Costs. The costs associated with drug testing shall be borne
by the motor carriers.